Arab Americans Seek Disadvantaged Minority Status

The U.S. Commerce Department is considering a petition to include Arab Americans on the list of socially and economically disadvantaged minority groups eligible for special business assistance.

The petition was submitted earlier this year by the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC) to make Arab Americans eligible for the Minority Business Development Agency (MBDA). The MBDA helps minority entrepreneurs establish and grow their businesses.

According to the ADC petition there has been an increase since 9/11 in "discrimination and prejudice in American society resulting in conditions under which Arab-American individuals have been unable to compete in a business world."

To support its claims, the ADC's petition emphasized the National Security Entry Exit Registration System, "which required non-immigrants to register at ports of entry and targeted males from Arab nations; stricter travel guidelines; and 'no-fly lists' that predominantly contained the names of Arab-Americans."

What the ADC petition ignored, however, were facts showing Arab Americans were more successful and better educated than the average American. Data from the U.S. Census Bureau from 2007-2009 showed that the mean individual income for Arab Americans was 27 percent higher than the national average and the percentage of Arab Americans with a bachelor's degree or higher was 45 percent compared to 28 percent for Americans at large.

The same patterns held true in the 2000 census and the 1990 census.

The Department of Commerce is investigating whether there is social and economic discrimination against Arab Americans and is seeking examples. The MBDA is scheduled to decide on the matter by June 27.

MBDA services are now offered to African-Americans, Puerto Ricans, Spanish-speaking Americans, American Indians, Eskimos, Aleuts, Hasidic Jews, Asian-Pacific Americans and Asian Indians.

Reader comments on this item

Ignorant

Nov 13, 2012 23:06

Not all Arabs are Muslim. Ignorance rears its ugly head again.

What Are These Arabs Contributing To America?

Submitted by Charlie Griffith, Jun 6, 2012 19:03

Before we create yet another group of entitlement-seekers-as-victims delving into our stretched budgets, we ought to ask these Arabs what specifically they're doing to actively combat the terrorism of their co-religionists (...assuming of course that these Arabs are all Muslims...).to justify receiving any financial or other "aid" leaving us open to the vulnerabilities of Islamic "lawfare".

Ask these Arabs to explain how their Koran permits them to live and benefit from our heretical, materialistic society? Isn't this hypocritical? Beware of taqiyya.

We should ask politically incorrect questions seeking explanation (s) such as are they as small or large groups or as individuals members of Hamas-affiliated C.A.I.R.? Are they members of a Muslim mosque? Have they sought financial help elsewhere?, if so, where, specifically?, as with what results? Is this a further claim of "victimhood"?

The aim of such pointed questions is to prevent opening us non-muslims up to charges of racism, "Islamophobia", and/or otherwise making us non muslims vulnerable to Islamist "lawfare" tactics.

This is a potential legal can of worms , and a potential opening wedge or precedent for justifying further claims as yet unknown natures.

In sum, be aware of precedent setting openings leading to unforseen circumstances.

Good luck.

Comment on this item